Welcome to the Sugar & Spice Bakery Page
Our recipes for our ever-popular Special K Chewies and Chocolate No-Bakes that you love haven't changed a bit...and we've also added some exciting new pastries! Stop by the IMU and see us! Not on the Indiana University campus anymore? No problem! We offer delivery anywhere USPS will ship.
We welcome special orders of items you see regularly in our store, or even of treats that only exist in your sweet dreams.
Contact us today to discuss what’s possible and place your order.
Sugar and Spice Chocolate Chunk Cookie is loaded with just the right amount of cookie dough and rich semi-sweet chocolate chunk pieces. The soft center with the slightest crisp at the edge lends out taste buds to grab the milk and enjoy an American tradition. –$25/dozen
- Chocolate Chunk Cookie Cake with Iced Border. Serves 10-12 people. –$25 each
If you like the combination of peanut butter and chocolate, this is your cookie! Bittersweet chocolate, oats, and peanut butter, combined to make one of our favorite cookies. –$22/dozen
- Mini Chocolate No Bake Cookies –$16/dozen
At IU, we love gingerbread. Our Gingerbread People have become a staple at the Sugar and Spice Bakery. Ginger boys or girls come in two sizes and decorations. The Cinnamon, Clove, and Ginger Cookie cut out is dressed with candy red hots. –$25/dozen
- Mini Gingerbread People –$16/dozen
- Extra Large Clothed Gingerbread Person (Traditional gingerbread with custom decorations) –$29 each
- Extra Large Plain Gingerbread Person (Traditional gingerbread with three cherry buttons and eyes) –$25 each
Our Traditional Iced Sugar cookies feature a white background with red IU letters or the red IU trident. Customized colors, designs, and shapes are available. –$28/dozen
Customized colors, designs, and shapes are available starting at $35/dozen.
- Iced Sugar Cookie Cake with border and inscription. Serves 10-12. – $25 each
Chocolate chips, M&M's, oats, and peanut butter—the best all-around cookie has everything one could ask for in a cookie and more. It’s a monster-sized cookie. –$25/dozen
Our version of the classic—fresh, chewy, and (a lot of) marshmallow goodness. –$22/dozen
- Mini Rice Krispie Treats – $16/dozen
Special K™ cereal and peanut butter, melted into a chewy cluster of goodness. $22/dozen
- Mini Special K™ Chewies – $16/dozen
Our hand-rolled Sugar Cookie is a favorite at IU. The sanding sugar for our sprinkled sugar comes in various bright colors, such as blue, dark purple, lime green, orange, red, and yellow. –$22/dozen
- Oversized Sprinkled Sugar Cookie Cake. Serves 10-12 people. – $20 each
Classic cakes are the pride and joy of Sugar & Spice. Each cake is specially made just for you. For convenience, you can choose to have your cake delivered locally, or pick it up at the store.
All cakes include standard decoration and may be inscribed. Special decorations may incur additional expenses. Please discuss options with your sales associate.
*Cake orders are not considered finalized until your order is confirmed by our staff.
Cake flavors include Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Cream & Crimson, Marble, and Carrot. Icing flavors include Vanilla, Chocolate Buttercream, and Cream Cheese. Additional Premier Flavors available upon request. Gluten-free and vegan options also available upon request.
- 9-inch round two-layer cake. Serves 16 –$25
- Single-layer quarter-sheet cake. Serves 24 –$25
- Single-layer half sheet cake. Serves 48 –$40
- Single-layer full sheet cake. Serves 96 –$57
Cupcake flavors include Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Cream & Crimson, and Carrot cake. Icing flavors include Vanilla, Chocolate Buttercream, and Cream Cheese.
Minimum order: 6 Cupcakes
We can create the cake of your dreams. Contact the IU Catering office for all custom cake orders: 812-855-1777.
Wells Cake was a favorite of beloved IU President Herman B Wells and was often requested for his dinner parties and celebrations. Famous for its light and refreshing qualities, Wells Cakes are made with bananas, fresh strawberries, layers of vanilla cake, and whipped cream icing.
Wells Cakes are for local pickup or delivery only.
$70 for a half sheet. Serves 48 people
Sugar & Spice Gift Boxes
Our gift boxes contain a delicious mix of fresh-baked cookies, sweets, and gourmet popcorn. Gourmet popcorn flavors include plain salted, caramel, cheddar, Cream & Crimson, chocolate caramel, and Chicago blend.
Two small bags of Gourmet Popcorn of your choosing, plus half a dozen Sugar and Spice Traditional Cookies (may include any combination of the following types of cookies: Iced Sugar Cookies, Gingerbread Cookies, Chocolate Chunk Cookies, Chocolate No-Bake Cookies, and Special K Caramel Chewies.)
Two medium bags of Gourmet Popcorn of your choosing and a dozen Sugar and Spice Traditional Cookies (may include any combination of the following types of cookies: Iced Sugar Cookies, Gingerbread Cookies, Chocolate Chunk Cookies, Chocolate No-Bake Cookies, and Special K Caramel Chewies.)