Sugar and Spice Order

Welcome to the Sugar & Spice Bakery Page

Sugar & Spice has been Indiana University's in-house bakery for over 50 years. We are located in the Indiana Memorial Union where we make delicious cookies, cupcakes, pastries, specialty and weddings cakes, and more.

Our recipes for our ever-popular Special K Chewies and Chocolate No-Bakes that you love haven't changed a bit...and we've also added some exciting new pastries! Stop by the IMU and see us! Not on the Indiana University campus anymore? No problem! We offer delivery anywhere USPS will ship.

Online Ordering

Online ordering is temporarily unavailable.

Please call 812-855-8810 to place your order.

You may also reach us by email at spiced@indiana.edu.

Cookies

Black and White Cookie

A shortbread dough cookie hand-dipped in chocolate and vanilla.

$1.99 each

Chocolate Chunk

Sugar and Spice Chocolate Chunk Cookie is loaded with just the right amount of cookie dough and rich semi-sweet chocolate chunk pieces. The soft center with the slightest crisp at the edge lends out taste buds to grab the milk and enjoy an American tradition.

$1.99 each

Chocolate Chunk Cookie Cake with Iced Border. Serves 10–12 people.

$23.99 each

Chocolate Chunk with Nuts

Sugar and Spice Chocolate Chunk Cookie is loaded with just the right amount of cookie dough and rich semi-sweet chocolate chunk pieces. The soft center with the slightest crisp at the edge lends out taste buds to grab the milk and enjoy an American tradition.

$2.09 each

Chocolate Chunk Cookie Cake with iced border. Serves 10–12 people.

$23.99 each

Chocolate No Bake Cookies

If you like the combination of peanut butter and chocolate, this is your cookie! Bittersweet chocolate, oats, and peanut butter, combined to make one of our favorite cookies.

$1.59 each

Gingerbread Man

The tastiest way to show your love for Indiana basketball. We took our signature gingerbread people and dressed them up for game day—complete with icing candy-stripe pants.

$4.49 each

Gingerbread People

At IU, we love gingerbread. Our Gingerbread People have become a staple at the Sugar and Spice Bakery. Ginger boys or girls come in two sizes and decorations. The Cinnamon, Clove, and Ginger Cookie cut out is dressed with candy red hots.

$1.99 each

EXTRA LARGE (Choose clothing or plain)

Clothed: Traditional gingerbread with custom decorations

$21.99

Plain: Traditional gingerbread with three cherry buttons and eyes

$19.99

Iced Sugar Cookies

Our Traditional Iced Sugar cookies feature a white background with red IU letters or the red IU trident. Customized colors, designs, and shapes are available.

$2.29 each

With border and inscription. Serves 10–12.

$23.99

Monster Cookies

Chocolate chips, M&M's, oats, and peanut butter—the best all-around cookie has everything one could ask for in a cookie and more. It’s a monster-sized cookie.

$2.29 each

Rice Krispie Treats

Our version of the classic—fresh, chewy, and (a lot of) marshmallow goodness.

$1.99 each

Special K Chewies

Special K cereal and peanut butter, melted into a chewy cluster of goodness. 

$1.59 each

Sprinkled Sugar Cookies

Our hand-rolled Sugar Cookie is a favorite at IU. The sanding sugar for our sprinkled sugar comes in various bright colors, such as blue, dark purple, lime green, orange, red, and yellow.

$1.59 each

Oversized Sprinkled Sugar Cookie Cake. Serves 10-12 people.

$10.99 each

Cakes

Classic Cakes are the pride and joy of Sugar and Spice. Each cake is specially made to fit each order and comes in a variety of ways to make them your own. For convenience, you can choose to have your cake delivered locally, or pick it up at the store. All specialty cakes come with the bottom and top borders, flowers, and an inscription.

*Cake orders will not be finalized until your order is confirmed by one of our bakery staff.

$24.99 for a quarter sheet cake. Serves 12–15 people

$24.99 for a 9-inch round two-layer cake. Serves 12–15 people

$39.99 for a half-sheet cake. Serves 25–30 people

$56.99 for a full-sheet cake. Serves 70–75 people

BASIC FLAVORS

  • Chocolate Cake
  • Marble Cake
  • White Cake
  • Yellow Cake

ICING FLAVORS

  • Chocolate icing
  • Vanilla icing

Cupcakes are available in a variety of flavors, including chocolate, red velvet, seasonal flavors, and vanilla with two types of icing: chocolate or vanilla.

Cupcakes are pickup or local delivery only.

$2.19 each

Call for specialty cakes.

Wells Cake was a favorite of beloved IU President Herman B Wells and was often requested for his dinner parties and celebrations. Famous for its light and refreshing qualities, Wells Cakes are made with bananas, fresh strawberries, layers of vanilla cake, and whipped cream icing.

Wells Cakes are for local pickup or delivery only.

$52.99 for a half sheet. Serves 30–35 people

$92.99 for a full sheet. Serves 75 people

Cake orders will not be finalized until your order is confirmed by one of our bakery staff. If you have any questions, please call 812-855-8810.

For customized wedding cakes please contact us at 812-855-8810.

Gift Packages

Carmel Apple

Cheddar Carmel

Chocolate Covered Cherry

Signature Cream and Crimson

Red and gold caramel popcorn drizzled with white chocolate, and topped with red milk chocolate candy pieces.

Turtle

Caramel popcorn with a milk chocolate drizzle.

  • Chocolate Chunks
  • Chocolate Chunks with Pecans
  • Chocolate No-Bake Cookies
  • Gingerbread
  • Rice Krispy Treats
  • Special K Chewy
  • Sugar Cookies with Icing
  • Sugar Cookies with Sprinkles

Sugar and Spice Popcorn Specialty Gift Box

Choose your favorite popcorn flavors.

Five bags $29.99

Three bags $17.99

Choose your favorite gourmet popcorn plus half a dozen customized Sugar and Spice Traditional Sugar Cookies.

$17.99 each

Three bags of your favorite gourmet popcorn plus half a dozen customized Sugar and Spice Traditional Sugar Cookies.

$17.99 each

Choose two flavors of your favorite gourmet popcorn plus one and a half dozen of your favorite Sugar and Spice Traditional Sugar Cookies. 

$34.99 each

Care Packages

happy-birthday-care-package.jpg

Don't forget their birthday! Our Happy Birthday package includes:

  • One candle for the cake
  • One custom round three-layer cake that serves 10–12 people
  • Utensils for 12
  • One voucher for a small bag of Birthday Cake-flavored popcorn, a voucher for Turtle popcorn, and vouchers for any large specialty drink from Sugar and Spice

$39.99

A healthy option for the mindful sweet tooth.

  • Two apples
  • One chocolate bar
  • Two Cliff Bars
  • Two Dasani water bottles
  • Two granola bars
  • Two oranges
  • One gluten-free Rice Krispy Treat from Sugar and Spice
  • One large Sea Salt Popcorn

$39.99

Ultimate-Finals-Survival-Kit.jpg

Everything you need to make it through Dead Week and Finals!

Includes:

  • One apple
  • Cliff bars
  • Two Dasani water bottles
  • Two boxes of Good to Go snack packs with almonds, candy, peanuts, and yogurt pretzels
  • One no-bake cookie
  • One orange
  • Ranch-flavored popcorn
  • One Special K caramel chewy
  • Two seasonal iced sugar cookies
  • Turtle popcorn
  • Vouchers for one large shake from The Chocolate Moose and one large specialty beverage from Sugar and Spice

$39.99

Welcome-to-Campus-Basket.jpg

Start their year off right with a care package delivered in late August.

Our IU-themed basket includes:

  • One apple
  • One Cliff Bar
  • Cream and Crimson Crunch Blend popcorn
  • One ginger IU Football cookie
  • Two iced IU sugar cookies
  • One no-bake cookie
  • One Kind Bar
  • One Special K caramel chewy
  • Vouchers for any ice cream cone from The Chocolate Moose and one large Sugar and Spice Specialty Coffee
  • White cheddar popcorn

$39.99

Winter-Exams-Survival-Kit.jpg

The Winter Exams Survival Basket, delivered in December and safely before your student's first round of exams.

Includes:

  • One apple
  • Cliff Bars
  • Two Dasani water bottles
  • Two boxes of Good to Go snack packs with almonds, candy, peanuts, and yogurt pretzels
  • Two seasonal iced sugar cookies
  • One no-bake cookie
  • One orange
  • Ranch-flavored popcorn
  • One Special K caramel chewy
  • Turtle popcorn
  • Vouchers for one large smoothie from The Chocolate Moose and one large specialty beverage from Sugar and Spice

sweet-surprise.jpg

Show your new or returning college student you love and miss them with our new Sugar and Spice Sweet Surprise Care Packages! We'll automatically send them different baskets throughout the year that are packed with classic cookies from Sugar and Spice, gourmet popcorn, and other awesome drinks and snacks. They will also receive coupons in each basket that can be redeemed for cookies or specialty drinks made fresh at Sugar and Spice, as well as popcorn and blended smoothies from The Chocolate Moose.

Throughout the year, your student will receive comforting and exciting treats. Regardless of your schedule, your student will know they in your thoughts.

$119.96 for four baskets

Choose from the following:

Birthday Basket

Delivered on a custom-set delivery date. Includes

  • A candle for the cake
  • A round three-layer cake from Sugar and Spice that serves 10–12 people
  • Utensils for 12 people
  • A voucher for a small bag of Birthday Cake-flavored popcorn
  • A voucher for turtle popcorn
  • Vouchers for any large specialty drink from Sugar and Spice

Welcome to Campus Basket

Delivered in mid August.

The IU-themed basket includes:

  • Admissions blend popcorn
  • Apple
  • Cliff Bar
  • Ginger IU Football cookie
  • Kind Car
  • No-bake cookie
  • Special K caramel chewy
  • Two iced IU sugar cookies
  • White cheddar popcorn
  • Special K caramel chewy
  • Vouchers for any ice cream cone from The Chocolate Moose and one large Sugar and Spice specialty coffee

Valentine`s Day Basket

Delivered in early February.

Includes:

  • Chocolate bar
  • Two ginger heart cookies
  • Three iced heart sugar cookie pops
  • Two Jo Jo salted caramels
  • Four Sugar and Spice chocoalte truffles in a gift box
  • Valentine's Day blend of chocolate covered strawberry popcorn
  • Vouchers for one large smoothie from The Chocolate Moose and one large specialty beverage from Sugar and Spice

The Ultimate Finals Survival Kit

Delivered in May before Finals Week. Everything you need to make it through your exams.

Includes:

  • Apple
  • Cliff Bars
  • Two Dasani water bottles
  • Two boxes of Good to Go snack packs with almonds, candy, peanuts, and yogurt pretzels
  • Two seasonal iced sugar cookies
  • No-bake cookie
  • Orange
  • Ranch-flavored popcorn
  • Special K caramel chewy
  • Turtle popcorn
  • K Caramel Chewy
  • Vouchers for one large smoothie from The Chocolate Moose and one large specialty beverage from Sugar and Spice

Healthy Living

  • Two apples
  • One chocolate bar
  • Two Cliff Bars
  • Two Dasani water bottles
  • Two granola bars
  • Two oranges
  • Gluten-free Rice Krispy Treat from Sugar and Spice
  • One large sea salt popcorn

Winter Exams Survival Basket

Delivered in December before finals week or in May before finals week.

Includes:

  • Apple
  • Cliff Bars
  • Two Dasani water bottles
  • Two boxes of Good to Go snack packs that include almonds, candy, peanuts, and yogurt pretzels
  • Two seasonal iced sugar cookies
  • No-bake cookie
  • Orange
  • Ranch-flavored popcorn
  • Special K caramel chewy
  • Turtle popcorn
  • Vouchers for one large smoothie from The Chocolate Moose and one large specialty beverage from Sugar and Spice

Add Additional Baskets for care packages throughout the year! Ordering all six baskets qualifies for free local delivery on all basket shipments. 

Item/Item Cost

Charge Per Shipment

$0.01–$50.00$17.00
$50.01–$100.00$20.50
$100.01 and more$24.50

Express Method

Charge Per Shipment

3–Day Express (3 business days)$10.50 per shipment + standard rate
2–Day Express (2 business days)$14.50 per shipment + standard rate
Overnight Express (Saturday delivery not included)$19.50 per shipment + standard rate
All oversized orders—either by size or by weight—must be quoted by our sales representative.

Policies

Shipping and Processing

Note: We only ship cookies.

All delivery days refer to business days—Monday through Friday, excluding holidays.

Standard shipping charges cover the costs incurred to prepare, process, and transport your order. Standard rates are based on UPS Ground Delivery within the continental United States. Other delivery methods are available but must be quoted for each order. We ship to most areas outside of the continental United States. Shipping charges vary by destination. When placing your order, please ask about shipping charges. We are unable to ship to P.O. boxes and APO addresses via UPS. 

UPS will deliver approximately between 8 a.m. until 8 p.m. (extended times may apply during the holidays). If you must have your gift delivered on a specific date, we suggest the use of overnight delivery to guarantee the delivery date.

Please check your address information carefully. We cannot extend our guarantee to orders with incorrect addresses. Areas impacted by extreme weather conditions may result in a delay in delivery. We thank you in advance for your understanding during these rare instances.

Any package unable for delivery due to incorrect information, untimely picked up by the recipient or when the recipient is no longer at the given address, which is then returned to Sugar and Spice, will not be refunded and will only be reshipped at the customer's cost and request.

Regarding untimely pickups: UPS will deliver the package at the delivery address without a signature unless the driver determines that the location is not sufficiently secure. If this happens, UPS will attempt to make a delivery up to three times. On the third attempt, a notice will be left for the recipient to pick up the package at a designated UPS depot. If delivery does not happen after these attempts are made, the perishable package will be sent back to Sugar and Spice.

Due to the abundance of holiday orders between November 15 and December 24: Orders must be placed at least five business days in advance to assure on-time delivery. During this period, orders over 10 items must be placed at a minimum of seven business days beforehand.